However, all good fortune is not meant to last. The First Porter explains how he got his job by looking upon Venus, and the only way he can be freed is by another guest who has also looked upon Venus and can take his place. This causes a lot of trouble.
After a leisurely afternoon and a feast, Atlas reads the list of duties each man must perform as a Knight of the Golden Stone:
1. You Lord Knights shall swear to ascribe your Order not to any devil or spirit, but only to God your Creator, and to Nature, his handmaiden.
2. You shall abominate all whoredom, incontinence, and uncleanness, and not defile your Order with such vices.
3. Through your gifts you shall willingly come to the aid of all who are deserving and in need.
4. You shall not desire this honor to use it for worldy show or high esteem.
5. You shall not wish to live longer than God wills.
They swear to them all on the King’s scepter, are installed as Knights, and then they are led into a chapel to give thanks to God. The King agrees to grant all men one wish. So he goes into a little closet and each man comes in one by one. When it is Christian’s turn, the King asks him to settle the score about the First Porter, and he spills all the details about how he saw Venus. Notice in this transaction, that the Page gets off. The King refuses to grant him his wish and he has to replace the Porter in the morning. To refuse would be a denial of his station as a Knight. The text ends with Christian mulling it over. Paradise denied.